Category: Poetry Brief | Sons and Mother

This time around I used Photoshop to create a rough animatic as I kept tweaking the frames throughout. When I added the sound I realized I was lacking in some scenes and one thing I barely achieved is the timing. For now I am quite satisfied with what I made but I think I can polish some scenes further, but I will know for sure after the lecture.

Story boarding

I felt the poem had a very uneasiness feel to it. I added a couple of frames in the story to set up the theme and poem e.g., the Diya plays a very important throughout the story because it is an essential object used when praying for the departed soul. Although it is not clear if the mother had died or not but is built around her essence. For the majority of the story we had more closeup shots and as we are traveling and tracking the smoke trail, it transitions from one thing to another. Another reason I chose such shots is because I wanted to go for a grim, dark and uneasy aesthetic.

Upon reading the poem a couple of times I go the sense that there is more than meets the eyes with this one. It seems as though the mother is dead and is written in her remembrance, but after an in-depth discussion with the poet I realized that it was more about how as a child our mothers smother and pamper us. When we get older, the things we did as children have become uncomfortable, but there is a loss in this experience, as well as a nostalgia and comfort. The striking match comes from the moment when the poet’s mother and him used to pray in a small temple, in their home, by lighting a diyo (which I is a plot device and will be basis of the whole story). I think growing up is like being in prayer, so much of it is in secret and by yourself. But overall, the poem is about trying to figure out what it means to be a son growing up and getting further away from my mother, yet still hoping for an closeness that is lost when growing up.

When researching other poetry animations I came across a familiar one that we were taught in our o-levels called “o des se aane wale bata” by Pakistani Poet “Akhtar Shirani”. There is a striking similarity between the two in the sense that both talk about lost times and want a chance to to relive those memories. Although the meaning might be different but tonally are same.

Below is an excerpt from the poem “o des se aane wale bata“. In these couple of lines the poet reminisces about this homeland e.g.,

کیا اب بھی وہاں کے باغوں میں مستانہ ہوائیں اتی ہیں ؟
کیا اب بھی وہاں کے پربت پر گھنگھور گھٹائیں چاہتی ہیں ؟
کیا اب بھی وہاں کے بر کھائیں ویسے ہی دلوں کو بھاتی ہیں ؟

Which translates to; him asking about “do the those warm airs in the lands still exist?, Does the sound of music still exist?, is the land still green?”

Hence, without drifting away from the task at hand, I devised a concept for the animation. Since the diya (a pinhole candle made of mud/ceramic) plays an essential part in the story, the concept revolves around it.

Concept

We are in a dark room and we see someone lighting a match. A hand appears from the pitch dark and lights a diya. We start to follow the smoke trail from the candle fire. The smoke itself is a character and it keeps transforming in to different objects. Not only this but the smoke is traveling throughout the room and showcasing what a mess the son is. The smoke trail in a way acts as our camera and travels 360 degrees in the room and connects back in to the fire from where it first emerged. We cut to a shot of a picture frame that contains a portrait of him and his mother (as this symbolizes that he is mourning lost times). There is a flower necklace around frame, similar to Hindu tradition when they mourn the departed.

Once I start story boarding only then I will get a sense of what the smoke and environment would look like.

References

Rekhta. (n.d.). Read full nazm by Akhtar Shirani. [online] Available at: https://www.rekhta.org/nazms/o-des-se-aane-vaale-bataa-o-des-se-aane-vaalaa-hai-bataa-akhtar-shirani-nazms [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023].‌

Wikipedia. (2023). Akhtar Sheerani. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akhtar_Sheerani [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023

‌

Before I started my ideation, I wanted to take a look at what had been done in term of poetry animations i.e., what type of visual story tellings were effective e.g., literal or symbolic ones. One thing that was clear from the very beginning was that no matter what approach I take I have to justify the source material while giving my own rendition.

Death and Mother by Robert Lingford (1997)

It is a Black-and-white, etched-wood animation tale about the Grim Reaper. In a remote forest, Death in disguise calls on a woman and her baby daughter. When the mother realises the identity of her visitor, and his intention to claim her child, she tries to flee the inevitable. Of course, try as she might, she cannot evade Death. Eventually, she accepts her fate when confronted with a window into her future. It is actually a short film that aired on Channel 4, but the concept is remotely similar my poem. The major selling points of this film are the transitions and I might take a note from this one in term of keeping the audience engaged through such means.

Jabberwocky by Lewis Carroll (1871)

Lewis Carroll’s “Jabberwocky” is a nonsense poem (from the 1871 novel “Through the looking glass”) in which many of the words are invented out of the author’s imagination. As a result, readers depend on Carroll to explain the meanings of such words. The story recounted in “Jabberwocky” is, at its heart, a very traditional heroic narrative in which an unassuming hero sets out to defeat an improbably dangerous enemy. For this reason, the boy’s success in slaying the Jabberwock evokes the most classic theme of heroic narrative: the triumph of good over evil. The animation is done at 3s (8 frames-per-second) with a stop motion and type feel. You can notice that there are moments when the words are independent of the imagery and this allows a more fluidity in the animation and I believe that a points where a more abstract approach is taken it turns out more effective.

“Humans” by Meghann Plunkett

The speaker boasts of human sophistication while addressing a silenced goldfish. It represents a sentiment of the vulnerable or the often unheard. It reveals a sense of arrogance in the human so boastful, impressed by human achievements and privileges, until midway through, the speaker flips the poem upside down. It encourages humility while exposing human fragility from the perspective of God looking at us as if we are now the goldfish. The poem confronts our assumptions about humanity and encourages us to ponder our perspective of self-centered importance in the universe. In this animation an additive combination approach is taken i.e., where the words amplify or elaborate on an image or vice versa.

“The World” by Rumi, A Poetry Film by Ella Dobson

The animation is made on the teachings of Rumi and a very challenging to animate as well because works by Rumi are so multi layered that there are many ways to interpret it. The above animation is very abstract and implies the method that, the more is said with words the more the pictures can be freed to go exploring and vice versa. Hence it relies on very crafty transitions.

In most of the animations I saw all of them either had an additive combination or Independent combination and one thing that was common throughout was that all employed crafty transitions when changing scenes (or lines) and these methods keep the audience engaged.

References

http://www.youtube.com. (n.d.). ‘How to Be Alone’ by Pádraig Ó Tuama, A Poetry Film by Leo G Franchi. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgZT6UJocRs.

http://www.youtube.com. (n.d.). Meghann Plunkett – ‘Humans’. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iP_xG0TiSD8 [Accessed 9 May 2021].

http://www.youtube.com. (n.d.). Lamya’s Poem | Official Trailer. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rtVkvAkgEc [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023].

‌www.youtube.com. (n.d.). The Country – Billy Collins Animated Poetry. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xovLpim_1s [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023].

‌www.youtube.com. (n.d.). South – A Visual Poetry. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4T1Lpx3pNI [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023].

‌TED-Ed (2020). ‘Jabberwocky’: One of literature’s best bits of nonsense. YouTube. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLQos7-Vq8M.

http://www.youtube.com. (n.d.). LA MADRE Y LA MUERTE (Death and the Mother) Ruth Lingford, 1997. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AR5zJrP0JkQ [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023].

‌

‌

‌

For the this semester we were given a project in which we were to create a 90 second animation based upon a poetry. The poetry project is a collaboration between the MA Animation students and the Poetry Society.

The Poetry Society

The Poetry Society is a charitable organisation, that provides support, information and merchandise for specialists and the general public. They engage with and support diverse poetry audiences. Founded in 1909 to promote “a more general recognition and appreciation of poetry”. Since then, it has grown into one of Britain’s most dynamic arts organisations, representing British poetry both nationally and internationally. With more than 5,000 members worldwide, it publishes the UK’s leading poetry magazine, The Poetry Review, which has been published since 1912. With innovative education and commissioning programmes and a packed calendar of performances, readings and competitions, The Poetry Society champions poetry for all ages.

Sons and Mothers (Ama ra Chora) by Mukahang Limbu

Sleeping on my mother’s bed, at my age, doesn’t 

feel so strange. It is warm, and the pillow 

smells like her hair. The blanket, her embrace. 

                                                                        ***

Sons are the mustard sweat stains on white collars. They need to be hand washed-

Sons are the skin hanging off sun-soaked lips. They need to be snipped with teeth-

Sons are the fingerprints of hands hidden in pockets. They need the need to be kept a secret-

Sons are the holes in orange socks. They need to be mended and sewn together as a closed mouth

***

I pray to God 

With a candle-

A wax pinhole with the face of the Moon.

Mother says,

Make milk.

I bathe my hands in the white.

Mother, makes me

Strike a match.

It burns like secrets spoken for the first time.

(My secret is that I always want to talk to you…)

I am a child that chases lost voices.

***

In front of God I am shy.

                                                I clasp hands.

                                                                                Sometime I even cry.

                                                                                                                                Because I ask.

                                                                                                                                                                For.        

    You.

Sleeping in your bed, at this age does not feel so strange, because that’s where I was born. In your arms.

Poets Explanation

I don’t remember the context of the poem, but I had written it during a time when I was growing up, and becoming my own person, outside of my relationship with my mother. It is thinking about how as we get older that the things we did as children have become uncomfortable, but there is a loss in this experience, as well as a nostalgia and comfort. The striking match comes from the moment when my mother and I prayed to our small temple, in our homes, by lighting a diyo. I think growing up is like being in prayer, so much of it is in secret and by yourself. But overall, I think I’m trying to figure out what it means to be a son growing up and getting further away from my mother, yet still hoping for an closeness that is lost when growing up.

References

poems.poetrysociety.org.uk. (n.d.). Sons and Mothers – The Poetry Society: Poems. [online] Available at: https://poems.poetrysociety.org.uk/poems/sons-and-mothers/ [Accessed 22 Apr. 2023].

‌